“We… we honestly didn’t know,” my mother whispered loudly, her hand flying up to clutch her pearl necklace, the color draining rapidly from her face. “She never told us a thing.”
“Because you were far too busy telling me I was utterly worthless to ever stop and ask,” I cut in, my voice slicing through her excuse like a scalpel.
I pivoted smoothly on my heel to face Mr. Sterling. “Counselor,” I said, my tone eerily calm. “You have just recklessly allowed your clients to commit blatant perjury on that stand. My father testified, under oath, that I maliciously ‘changed the locks’ on the family home to isolate my grandmother. In the second section of that folder I provided, you will find a sworn, notarized affidavit from the Director of the Oakwood Care Facility. It clearly states they were forced to change the locks, and secure a restraining order, because my father attempted to breach the facility while heavily intoxicated and physically aggressive toward the nursing staff two years ago.”
Sterling turned a sickly shade of ash gray. He whipped his head around to stare at my father with a look of dawning horror.
“Furthermore,” I continued, pacing a tight, disciplined line. “My mother testified under oath that I have zero income and was financially desperate. My certified IRS tax returns for the last five years are tabbed in that folder. I make a very comfortable, stable living. I possessed zero financial motive whatsoever to coerce my grandmother. My parents, on the other hand…”
I walked calmly back to my defense table and picked up a single sheet of paper I had kept hidden beneath my legal pad.
“Your Honor, I now formally petition this court to allow me to cross-examine the plaintiff, Robert Vance. Now that his credibility has been thoroughly and demonstrably impeached, I believe the court needs to hear the truth.”
Judge Halloway nodded slowly, the faintest hint of a predatory smile touching the corners of her lips. “Permission is enthusiastically granted. Mr. Vance, I remind you that you are still under oath. Take the stand.”
My father rose from his chair. The swagger was gone. He walked toward the witness box with the heavy, dragging steps of a man walking directly to the gallows. He refused to look in my direction. He cast a desperate, pleading look at his lawyer, but Sterling was furiously rifling through his messy briefcase, aggressively looking for any loophole, any exit strategy to save his own license.
Checkmate, I thought, as I stepped into the center of the room.
Chapter 6: The House of Cards Collapses
“Mr. Vance,” I began, standing squarely in the middle of the floor. I didn’t hold any notes. I didn’t need them. I had memorized his financial ruin weeks ago. “You testified earlier today, quite passionately, that your sole motivation for attempting to overturn this valid will was to ‘protect the family legacy.’ Is that a correct recollection of your testimony?”
“Yes,” he mumbled, staring at the microphone in front of him. “It’s… it’s about the principle of the thing.”
“I see. Is it also about the ‘principle’ that you are currently two point one million dollars in arrears to three different syndicates and casinos in Atlantic City?”
“Objection!” Sterling yelled, leaping up, though his voice was noticeably weak and devoid of its prior theatricality. “Relevance, Your Honor! This is a baseless character assassination!”
“It goes directly to the heart of motive, Your Honor,” I countered smoothly, never breaking eye contact with the man sweating profusely in the witness box. “The plaintiffs have spent hours claiming I was desperate and needed this money. I am currently establishing, with documentary evidence, that they are the ones in a state of catastrophic financial desperation.”
“The objection is emphatically overruled,” Judge Halloway snapped. “You will answer the question, Mr. Vance. And remember the penalty for perjury.”
My father began to sweat. A bead of perspiration rolled down his temple, catching the fluorescent light. “I… I have incurred some debts recently. Everyone in business has debts. It’s leverage.”
“Do you currently have a second, high-interest mortgage on your primary residence that is currently ninety days in default?” I asked, my voice snapping like a whip.
“I… maybe. It’s a misunderstanding with the bank.”
“And did Nana Rose know about this crippling, secretive debt?”
“I don’t know what that old woman knew,” he spat defensively.
“She did,” I said softly, allowing the silence to hold the weight of the revelation. “She knew, because I was the one who told her. I told her the afternoon after she received a highly threatening phone call from a third-party collection agency that was desperately hunting for you.”
I took three slow, deliberate steps closer to the witness stand.
“Nana Rose did not leave the entirety of her estate to me because I tricked her, Dad. She didn’t leave it to me because I manipulated a broken mind. She left it to me to protect it from you. She knew, with absolute certainty, that if you got your trembling hands on her life’s work, that four point seven million dollars would be entirely vaporized in less than a month at the high-stakes blackjack tables.”
My father looked desperately toward the jury box—which was entirely empty, as this was a bench trial—and then up at the judge. His shoulders collapsed inward. The facade of the wealthy, untouchable Connecticut aristocrat crumbled into dust right before my eyes.
“We needed that money, Elena,” he whispered, his voice cracking into a pathetic whine. “We’re going to lose the house. The club memberships. Everything.”
“And so your grand solution was to maliciously frame your own daughter for elder fraud,” I stated, the disgust finally leaking into my tone. “You sat in this room and decided to drag my name through the mud, to publicly brand me a loser, a drifter, a common thief… all to cover up your own pathetic, gambling-induced mistakes.”
I turned away from him, thoroughly nauseated by the sight of his collapse. I looked up at the bench. “I have no further questions for this witness, Your Honor. The defense rests.”
Judge Halloway did not hesitate for a fraction of a second.
“The Plaintiff’s case is hereby deemed entirely without merit,” she ruled, her voice ringing out like thunder. “The testimony provided today by Robert and Linda Vance is officially deemed thoroughly unreliable, malicious, and perjurious. The Last Will and Testament of Rose Vance stands valid and uncontested.”
She brought the heavy wooden gavel down with a deafening CRACK.
“Furthermore,” Judge Halloway continued, her eyes locking onto a trembling Mr. Sterling. “I am dismissing this frivolous lawsuit with extreme prejudice. And, Mr. Sterling, I am officially ordering your clients to pay every single cent of the legal costs incurred by the estate during this circus. Lastly, I am forwarding the unedited transcript of today’s proceedings directly to the District Attorney’s office, with my strongest personal recommendation to immediately investigate both Robert and Linda Vance for felony perjury and attempted estate fraud.”
A piercing shriek erupted from the plaintiff’s table. “Arrest? Jail? You can’t do that!” my mother screamed. She scrambled out of her chair, her Chanel suit wrinkling as she practically ran across the room toward me.